| Cashier # | Name | Dates in Office | Duggleby refs | |
| 1 | John Kendrick | 1694 | ||
| 2 | Thomas Speed | 1694 - 1699 | ||
| 3 | Thomas Madockes | 1699 - 1739 | ||
| 4 | James Collier and Daniel Race | 1739 - 1751 | ||
| 5 | Daniel Race and Elias Simes | 1751 - 1759 | ||
| 6 | Daniel Race | 1759 - 1775 | ||
| 7 | Charles Jewson | 1775 - 7th January 1778 | ||
| 8 | Abraham Newland | 8th January 1778 - 17th september 1807 | B200a - B200r | |
| 9 | Henry Hase | 17th September 1807 - 26th March 1829 | B201a - B201h | |
| 10 | Thomas Rippon | 27th March 1829 - 13th August 1835 | B202a - B202b | |
| 11 | Matthew Marshall | 17th September 1835 - 16th June 1864 | B203a - B203j | |
| 12 | William Miller | 23rd June 1864 - 29th November 1866 | B204a - B204b | |
| 13 | George Forbes | 6th December 1866 - 30th June 1873 | B205a - B205d | |
| 14 | Frank May | 1st July 1873 - 9th November 1893 | B206a - B206d | |
| 15 | Horace George Bowen | 9th November 1893 - January 1902 | B207a - B207b | |
| 16 | John Gordon Nairne | January 1902 - 5th May1918 | B208a - B208i | |
| 17 | Ernest Musgrave Harvey | 6th May 1918 - 30th March 1925 | B209a - B209h | |
| 18 | Cyril Patrick Mahon | 1st April 1925 - 26th March 1929 | B210 - B222 | |
| 19 | Basil Gage Catterns | 27th March 1929 - 17th April 1934 | B223 - B234 | |
| 20 | Kenneth Oswold Peppiatt | 18th April 1934 - 28th February 1949 | B235 - B264 | |
| 21 | Percival Spencer Beale | 1st March 1949 - 16th January 1955 | B265 - B270 | |
| 22 | Leslie Kenneth O'Brien | 17th January 1955 - 28th February 1962 | B271 - B287 | |
| 23 | Jasper Quintus Hollom | 1st March 1962 - 30th June 1966 | B288 - B300 | |
| 24 | John Standish Fforde | 1st July 1966 - 28th February 1970 | B301 - B319 | |
| 25 | John Brangwyn Page | 1st March 1970 - 29th February 1980 | B320 - B340 | |
| 26 | David Henry Fitzroy Somerset | 1st March 1980 - 28th February 1988 | B341 - B352 | |
| 27 | George Malcolm Gill | 1st March 1988 - 24th November 1991 | B353 - B359 | |
| 28 | Graham Edward Alfred Kentfield | 25th November 1991 - 31st December 1998 | B360 - B379 | |
| 29 | Merlyn Vivienne Lowther | 1st January 1999 - 31st December 2003 | B380 - B397 | |
| 30 | Andrew John Bailey | 1st January 2004 - 31st March 2011 | B398 - B406 | |
| 31 | Chris Salmon | 1st April 2011 - 31st May 2014 | B407 - B410 | |
| 32 | Victoria Cleland | 1st June 2014 - 31st May 2018 | B411 - B415 | |
| 33 | Sarah John | 1st June 2018 - | B416 - |